1. Guides
  2. Where Can I Sell My Action Figures: A Comprehensive Guide

Where Can I Sell My Action Figures: A Comprehensive Guide

May 20, 2024
sell my action figure

Are you ready to part ways with your beloved action figure collection, but unsure where to start? Fear not, fellow collectors! In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore various platforms, tips, and tricks to help you answer the question, “Where can I sell my action figures?” So let’s dive in and turn your collectibles into cold, hard cash!

Key Takeaways

  • Evaluate your collection to determine its value and condition before selling!
  • Explore online marketplaces, apps, local buyers & toy stores for great potential in sales.
  • Maximize profits with research, cleaning & packaging, authenticity is key!

Evaluating Your Action Figure Collection

Before you start selling, an assessment of your action figure collection’s value and condition is vital. Factors such as rarity, brand popularity (think Star Wars, Marvel Legends, and Funko Pops), and packaging play a significant role in determining the worth of your collectibles. But how do you discover the current market value of your action figures? Fear not, intrepid collector! With the help of online price guides and magazines, you can research their worth and become an expert in no time.

After establishing your vintage action figures’ worth, you can start listing them for sale. Be sure to include essential details like:

  • The character’s name
  • The series they’re from
  • Their age
  • Their condition

And if you have a certificate of authenticity, don’t forget to mention it! With this knowledge in hand, we can delve into the plethora of online platforms where you can sell your action figures.

Online Marketplaces to Sell Action Figures

When it comes to selling action figures, online marketplaces like eBay, Amazon Marketplace, and Fiddlepiddle offer fantastic platforms to showcase your collectibles. Each marketplace has its own unique advantages and limitations, so let’s dive deeper into each option to find the perfect fit for you and your action figures.

eBay: Auctions and Buy-It-Now Options

eBay, a popular online marketplace, offers both auction and buy-it-now options for selling your collectible action figures. While auctions can be thrilling, they may result in lower prices for your action figure collections. To maximize your profits, consider selling individual action figures or your neca action figure collection rather than collections in bulk. And don’t forget to factor in shipping costs and additional fees when setting your prices.

Ensure a seamless eBay selling experience by taking the following steps:

  1. Take high-quality photos of your action figures.
  2. Give accurate descriptions of your action figures.
  3. Make your items shine with top-notch photos. By showcasing your action figures in the best light, you’ll attract potential buyers and boost your chances of making a sale.

Amazon Marketplace: High Prices but Restrictions Apply

Amazon Marketplace is another popular platform for selling action figures, allowing you to tap into a vast customer base. While it’s possible to list and sell action figures at higher prices on Amazon, there are some restrictions to keep in mind. For instance, sellers must adhere to Amazon’s pricing and shipping policies, which may limit your flexibility. Additionally, Amazon charges a seller fee of about 15% plus other fees, so factor those into your pricing strategy.

Although there are restrictions, listing action figures on Amazon Marketplace is straightforward and only takes a few clicks. To maximize your chances of success, focus on providing clear and honest descriptions, and consider listing only sealed figures to meet Amazon’s strict condition requirements.

Fiddlepiddle: A Platform Dedicated to Collectibles

For those looking to sell their action figures on a platform dedicated to collectibles, look no further than Fiddlepiddle! This exciting marketplace allows you to list and sell your action figures without any listing fees, taking only a 5% commission on sales.

To start selling on Fiddlepiddle, simply follow these steps:

  1. Create an account on the platform.
  2. List your collectibles with detailed descriptions and photos.
  3. Showcase your action figures on a platform tailored for collectors.
  4. Increase your chances of connecting with the right buyers and making a successful sale.

Selling Apps: Mercari and WhatNot

Another option for selling your action figures is through popular selling apps like Mercari and WhatNot. While sales on Mercari may be slower compared to eBay and Amazon, WhatNot offers a unique live sales experience that can result in high selling prices if you build your customer base. However, it’s important to note that WhatNot has a strict approval process for sellers, requiring social media accounts, references, and feedback from other platforms like eBay and Amazon.

Even with the challenges, Mercari and WhatNot can prove to be fruitful platforms for selling action figures. By tailoring your listings to each app’s specific audience and requirements, you can boost your chances of securing a successful sale.

Local Buyers and Toy Stores

If a traditional approach is more to your liking, selling your action figures to local buyers or toy stores could be a good option. While these options may provide a quicker and easier way to sell your collectibles, they may not offer the highest profits due to their need for a profit margin.

To find local buyers for your collectible toys, check out collectibles stores, Facebook Marketplace, and Craigslist. Before selling to a local buyer, research their reputation and ensure they have positive reviews. If their offer isn’t satisfactory, don’t be afraid to move on to the next person. By exploring various local options, you can find the perfect buyer to sell toys like your action figures.

Utilizing Social Media and Online Forums

Social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram, along with online forums, can be effective avenues for selling action figures. Success on these platforms may vary depending on the popularity of your figures and your online presence.

To get started, create engaging posts showcasing your action figures and share them with relevant groups, hashtags, and communities. Keep in mind that less popular or niche toys may struggle to find buyers on these platforms, but don’t let that discourage you. With perseverance and creativity, you can harness the power of social media to find the perfect new home for your action figures.

Tips for Maximizing Profit When Selling Action Figures

Here are some tips to maximize your profit when selling action figures:

  1. Research their value using online resources, especially for loose action figures.
  2. Clean your figures to make them look their best.
  3. Keep their original packaging to increase their worth.
  4. Set realistic prices based on your research.

By following these guidelines, you’ll not only increase the chances of making a sale but also ensure that you’re getting the most value for your toy collections. Remember, knowledge is power – so arm yourself with information and make informed decisions when selling or collecting action figures!

Authenticity and Appraisals

Verifying the authenticity of your action figures is a necessary step before selling them. Consulting professional appraisers or grading services like Collector Archive Services (CAS), the Collectible Grading Authority (CGA), or the Action Figure Authority (AFA) can help you verify your figures’ authenticity and determine their value.

In addition to professional services, there are several online resources available for authenticating action figures, such as the AFA and CGA. By confirming the authenticity of your action figures, you’ll not only protect yourself and potential buyers but also increase the value and appeal of your collectibles.

Shipping and Handling Considerations

Following a sale, it’s imperative to package and ship your action figures appropriately to guarantee their safe arrival. Here’s how:

  1. Start by finding a box that fits the figure nicely. Make sure to leave some breathing room around the figure.
  2. Fill the empty space with bubble wrap, packing paper, or peanuts.
  3. Wrap the figure itself in bubble wrap. Be careful not to wrap too tightly, as this may damage the packaging.

After packing your action figures securely, seal the box with packing tape and mark it with a fragile sticker, if appropriate. By taking the time to package your figures properly, you’ll ensure they reach their new owners in tip-top shape, leading to satisfied customers and successful transactions.

Handling Returns and Buyer Complaints

Handling returns and buyer complaints is part and parcel of selling action figures. To address these issues, respond quickly and professionally, listen to customer feedback, offer fair and reasonable solutions, and follow up to ensure satisfaction.

Additionally, minimize potential issues by providing clear photos and honest descriptions of your action figures, including any loose figures, in your toy collection. By being transparent about the condition and features of your collectibles, you’ll reduce the likelihood of returns and complaints, leading to a smoother selling experience.


In conclusion, selling your action figures can be a rewarding and profitable endeavor. By researching their value, choosing the right platform, and following best practices for packaging and customer service, you can turn your beloved collection into a successful sale. So go forth, fellow collectors, and transform your action figures into a treasure trove of newfound wealth!

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I sell my action figures?

Based on the provided text, it appears to be a single paragraph. Here is the split into paragraphs: Paragraph 1: Gain an understanding of the value of your action figures and then use online selling platforms like Amazon Marketplace, eBay, or Fiddlepiddle to put them up for sale. You can also try selling via apps and social media, or take them to a local toy or collectible store.

Do pawn shops buy action figures?

Yes, pawn shops do buy action figures – a great option for you to get cash quickly for your toys!

What action figures are the easiest to sell?

GI Joe action figures from the 1960s and 70s are the easiest to sell, particularly when sold in lots. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles figures from the 1980s are also profitable if they’re still sealed.

How to sell figures online?

Sell your vintage toys and action figures on eBay – whether in their original packaging or loose. You can choose to auction them off or set a “buy it now” price. Make sure to include a clear conclusion in your listing and use an excited tone to attract buyers.

What online marketplaces can I use to sell my action figures?

Sell your action figures on popular online marketplaces such as eBay, Amazon Marketplace, and Fiddlepiddle for maximum visibility!